Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare what renting and buying would cost over the same period. The calculator includes mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, maintenance, selling costs, home appreciation and what a down payment could have earned if invested instead.

Financial • Net cost comparison • Opportunity cost • Updated November 18, 2026 • Reviewed by the GlobalCalcly editorial team
Home and rent details Use the same time horizon for both options
$
%
%
yrs
%/yr
$ /yr
%/yr
%/yr
%
%
$
%/yr
%/yr
yrs
Net cost of buying
—

Enter the home, mortgage and rent details to compare.

Net cost of renting —
Years compared —
Buying minus renting —
Monthly cost to own —
Monthly rent —
Equity after selling costs —
Mortgage interest paid —
Estimated home value —
Cheaper over this period —

Why the comparison is not just rent versus mortgage

A mortgage payment is only one part of owning a home. Property taxes, insurance, maintenance, closing costs and selling costs all add to the real cost. On the other side, part of every mortgage payment builds equity, and the home itself may rise in value.

Renting has its own hidden cost: the down payment and closing money could have been invested. The calculator compares the two options on a net-cost basis over the same number of years, so the result reflects money actually spent or kept.

What goes into each side

Buy: down payment + closing costs + mortgage payments + taxes + insurance + maintenance + selling costs − home value
Rent: total rent paid − investment growth on the down payment and closing costs

The home value is subtracted because it is an asset you still own after the period, net of the remaining mortgage and selling costs. For renting, the investment growth is subtracted because that money would have grown if it had not been tied up in a house.

Worked example

A 400,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% over 30 years has a principal-and-interest payment of about 2,023. Adding taxes, insurance and maintenance brings the monthly ownership cost to roughly 2,797. Renting the same home for 2,200 a month looks cheaper each month, but after ten years of appreciation and principal repayment, the net cost of buying may be lower depending on the assumptions.

The time horizon matters

Buying usually involves large upfront costs. Those costs need time to be offset by equity and appreciation, so a short stay often favours renting. A longer stay gives the upfront costs more time to spread out and allows more of each payment to go to principal.

Assumptions to check

The result depends heavily on appreciation, investment return and how long you stay. Small changes in these assumptions can flip the answer. Try a few scenarios rather than treating one result as definitive.

The calculator assumes the home is sold at the end of the period and that selling costs are a percentage of the sale price. It assumes property taxes and maintenance are based on the original price, which is a simplification. It also ignores landlord-provided services, renter’s insurance and any tax deductions on mortgage interest.

Costs that are easy to forget

Moving costs, furnishing, repairs discovered after purchase, homeowner association fees and special assessments can all shift the balance. On the rental side, security deposits, renter’s insurance and annual rent increases matter. Include the ones that apply to your situation when interpreting the result.

Risk and flexibility

Owning a home concentrates a large amount of money in one asset. Renting keeps more capital liquid and makes it easier to move for work or lifestyle reasons. The cheaper option on paper is not always the better choice if flexibility or diversification matters to you.

When to break even

There is no universal break-even year. It depends on local prices, rent levels, mortgage rates, transaction costs and expected appreciation. A market with high closing costs and slow appreciation needs a longer stay before buying pulls ahead. Use the year-by-year inputs to test your own assumptions.

Not financial advice

This is an educational comparison, not a recommendation. Tax rules, local housing markets and personal circumstances vary. Speak to a financial professional before making a large housing decision.

What changes the number most

Appreciation is the loudest input. On a 350,000 home, three percent a year adds about 10,500 in the first year, which is larger than the annual rent-versus-ownership gap that most comparisons turn on. Set appreciation to zero and the same purchase looks far worse; set it to six percent and almost any purchase wins, which is why one optimistic rate can carry the whole answer.

The return assumed on the down payment works the same way in reverse. Forty five thousand five hundred in cash, ten percent down plus closing costs, at five percent earns roughly 2,275 in a year, so a higher assumed return quietly favours renting by that amount annually.

Maintenance and vacancy matter less per year but compound over a decade. One percent of value is 3,500 a year on this home; moving to two percent adds another 35,000 across ten years, enough to erase a modest advantage.

What the result means

The output is a net cost, not a monthly payment. Each side totals everything spent, then credits what is left over: home equity at sale for buying, the investment balance for renting. A difference of 20,000 after ten years means one path left you 20,000 better off, not that the monthly bills differed by that much.

Check the sign and the size together. A gap under about two percent of the purchase price sits inside the error of the assumptions and is better read as a tie than as a verdict.

Common mistakes to avoid

Comparing rent with principal and interest only is the biggest one. Taxes, insurance, maintenance and selling costs at exit belong in the buy column. On the rent side, leaving out annual increases flatters renting, while ignoring growth on the deposit flatters buying.

Also avoid holding the period fixed while varying everything else, then treating one run as the answer. Run several scenarios and look for the range in which the decision holds.

Frequently asked questions

Does the calculator include property taxes and insurance?

Yes. It adds annual property tax, home insurance and maintenance to the buying side, then deducts selling costs when the home is valued at the end. Replace the defaults with figures from a real tax bill and an insurance quote.

Why is investment return included for renting?

Because the cash tied up in a purchase could have been earning elsewhere. The calculator compounds the deposit and closing costs at your assumed return, then subtracts that balance from the rent side so both options start from the same wealth.

Is buying always cheaper over the long run?

No. Local prices, rents, mortgage rates and transaction costs decide it, and a long stay only helps when appreciation and equity outrun those costs. In markets with high closing costs and flat prices, renting can stay ahead indefinitely.

What is the break-even point?

The year when cumulative buying costs fall below cumulative renting costs. It is not a fixed number: raising appreciation or lengthening the stay moves it earlier, while higher selling costs or a bigger deposit move it later.

Does it account for tax deductions?

No. Mortgage interest relief and property tax deductions vary by country and by personal circumstances, so including them would make the result wrong for most readers. Subtract your own benefit from the buying side if one applies.

Sources & methodology

Educational information only — not financial, tax or investment advice. Confirm important decisions with a qualified professional.