Loan Comparison Calculator
Put two loan offers next to each other. Enter the amount, interest rate and term for each option to compare monthly payments, total interest and total cost.
Enter the amount and the rate and term for each loan.
What to compare in two loan offers
A lower rate is not automatically the cheaper loan. A longer term reduces the monthly payment but usually increases the total interest. Comparing payment, total cost and total interest together gives a clearer picture.
P = amount · r = monthly rate · n = number of monthly payments
The monthly rate is the annual rate divided by 12 and by 100. A 6% annual rate becomes 0.005 per month.
A worked example
Borrowing $25,000 at 6.5% over 5 years costs about $489 a month and $4,349 in interest. At 5.9% over 6 years the payment is about $413, but total interest rises to about $4,742.
Loan B is cheaper each month by about $76, yet Loan A costs about $393 less in interest overall. The right choice depends on whether cash flow or total cost matters more.
Fees and APR
Origination fees, closing costs and required insurance are not in the interest rate. The annual percentage rate, or APR, folds many of these costs into a single comparable figure. Ask for the APR as well as the note rate.
A loan with a low rate and a large fee can cost more than a slightly higher rate with no fees. Compare the total amount paid, including fees, before deciding.
Term length trade-offs
Stretching a loan lowers the payment but keeps the balance outstanding longer. More months of interest usually outweigh the smaller payment. Shorter terms build equity or clear debt faster but require more cash each month.
Check whether either loan has a prepayment penalty. If not, you can choose the longer term for safety and pay extra to finish early, though discipline is required.
Beyond the numbers
Service quality, repayment flexibility, late fee rules and customer support matter too. A lender that is hard to reach can cost time and stress even when the rate looks good.
Read the agreement for variable-rate clauses, balloon payments and mandatory add-ons. These features can change the real cost substantially.
Limitations
This comparison assumes fixed rates, equal monthly payments and no fees. It does not include taxes, insurance, origination charges or late fees. Use it to narrow the options, then confirm the full cost with each lender.
What changes the number most
Term length moves the payment far more than the rate does. On $20,000 at 7%, five years costs about $396 a month and $3,760 in interest; stretching to seven years drops the payment to roughly $302 but raises total interest to about $5,360.
Rate changes are gentler at these levels: moving from 7% to 9% on the five-year loan adds about $19 a month and roughly $1,150 of interest.
On a larger balance or a longer term the rate matters far more, because interest accrues on the outstanding amount for more months.
Fees behave like a rate rise concentrated at the start, so a 2% origination fee on a five-year loan is comparable to roughly 0.4 points of extra interest each year.
Common mistakes to avoid
Comparing payments only ignores the tail. A loan that saves $94 a month can cost $1,600 more overall, and the payment figure is what people remember.
Mixing a rate with an APR compares different things; a 6% note with a 2% fee can cost more than a 6.5% note with none.
Entering the annual rate as a monthly one shrinks the payment sharply. Seven percent a year is about 0.58% a month, while applying 7% monthly would imply a rate near 125% a year.
Quoting the term in years in one column and months in the other is a quieter version of the same mistake, and both errors survive a glance at the payment figure.
How to check the result
Multiply the payment by the month count and subtract the principal: 396 × 60 = 23,760, and 23,760 − 20,000 leaves $3,760 of interest.
A shorter term at the same rate must always show a higher payment and lower total interest. If both fall, the amounts or terms differ between the columns.
A rough check on any fixed-rate loan: at 7% over five years, total interest lands near 19% of the principal, consistent with $3,760 on $20,000.
Total payments should stay well below twice the principal unless the term runs past fifteen years at these rates.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare two loans?
Put the monthly payment, total interest and total amount paid side by side, then add fees to each. A shorter term usually wins on total cost while losing on cash flow. Ask for the APR so the fee difference is captured in one number.
Is a lower monthly payment always better?
No, because a smaller payment often comes from a longer term, and more months of interest can cost far more overall. Moving from five to seven years on $20,000 at 7% saves $94 a month but adds about $1,600 of interest. Weigh both.
What is the difference between rate and APR?
The interest rate prices only the borrowed balance, while APR also folds in many fees and charges as one annual figure. A 6% note with a 2% fee spread over five years can show an APR near 6.4%. Compare APRs when fees differ.
Should I choose the shorter term?
Yes, if you can afford the higher payment without draining savings. The shorter term clears the balance faster and almost always costs less in interest. Keep an emergency fund first, so a lost job does not force a new loan.
Does this calculator include fees?
No, it compares the note rate only. Add origination, closing and documentation fees to the total amount paid before judging. A 2% fee on $20,000 is $400, which can exceed the saving from a rate half a point lower.
Can I pay off either loan early?
Only if the agreement has no prepayment penalty, so read the terms before assuming early repayment is free. Where penalties are absent, choosing the longer term and paying extra gives flexibility, provided you actually make the extra payments. Ask the lender to confirm in writing.
Sources & methodology
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — loan estimates and APR disclosure.
- National Institute of Standards and Technology — amortisation mathematics.
- Calculation method: standard fixed-rate amortisation for each offer, compared on payment and total interest.
Educational information only — not financial, tax or investment advice. Confirm important decisions with a qualified professional.